Taylor Swift Returns to the CMAs Tonight, and Nashville Still Can’t Agree Whether She Belongs

Updated

Taylor Swift at the 6th Annual Academy Museum Gala at the Academy Museum of Motion Pictures in Los Angeles

Taylor Swift is scheduled to give her first CMA Awards performance in 13 years tonight, Nov. 18, with “I Knew It, I Knew You” nominated for single of the year. The Toy Story 5 song brings her back into country’s awards race 12 years after she released her first fully pop album, 1989, and renews a question about how the genre decides who belongs.

For country music historian and Belmont professor Don Cusic, a recording’s sound alone can’t settle that question. Radio programmers, industry relationships and listeners all help determine an artist’s place in the community: “It’s being accepted by the country music audience that defines country,” he said.

Swift’s current single has reached No. 1 on country radio and Hot Country Songs, giving her a country radio chart-topper for the first time in more than a decade. She hosted radio professionals at a private listening event at her family’s Forrest Hills home in June and followed with prerecorded interviews promoting the song on Sept. 5.

Her musical relationships have also continued across the genre, including work with Chris Stapleton, Keith Urban, Maren Morris, Lainey Wilson, Kane Brown and The Chicks.

Swift remains the youngest-ever CMA Entertainer of the Year, an award she won in 2009. Her last CMA performance was an acoustic “Red” with Alison Krauss and Vince Gill in 2013, the night she also received the Pinnacle Award.

Awards recognition has varied across those returns. Swift performed “Betty,” with its pedal steel and harmonica, at the 2020 ACM Awards, and the song reached country radio without earning a country award nomination.

“I Knew It, I Knew You” now has a Grammy nomination as well as her 26th CMA nomination, while her pop album The Life of a Showgirl is also Grammy-nominated. Swift greeted the CMA nomination on Instagram: “LOOKS LIKE I HAVEN’T YEE’D MY LAST HAW.”

Taylor Swift at the Oscars
Taylor Swift photographed at the Oscars. Photo by Emma McIntyre / Getty Images.

Nashville’s public tributes offer conflicting answers about her place there. Brad Paisley took Swift’s spot on the Legends Corner mural after its owners decided to replace her in December 2020. His painted cowboy hat still leaves a small patch of her hair visible.

Paisley himself welcomed Swift into the Nashville Songwriters Hall of Fame on Oct. 26 with the words, “She is first and foremost one of us.” He’d brought her on tour at 17; she became the Hall of Fame’s youngest inductee. Lainey Wilson, this year’s CMA host, performed a bluegrass version of “Love Story” at the induction.

A different reception accompanied her prerecorded tribute to Alan Jackson at his June 27, 2025 farewell concert at Nissan Stadium. The crowd’s mixed cheers and boos were loud enough to make parts of her message hard to hear. The reason for the hostility wasn’t clear.

The contrast between Beyoncé’s Cowboy Carter and Post Malone’s reception in Nashville figures in Beverly Keel’s argument about unequal treatment. Keel, dean of Middle Tennessee State University’s Scott Borchetta College of Media and Entertainment, sees a particular penalty for women who cross genre lines: Shania Twain and Faith Hill faced criticism, while crossover success didn’t cost Florida Georgia Line its country radio support.

Cusic points to the established country artists who helped Malone gain acceptance through collaborations: Dolly Parton, Blake Shelton, Morgan Wallen and Luke Combs. University of Michigan musicologist Nadine Hubbs sees another advantage in Swift’s case, the scale of the audience she can bring with her.

“If you want to bring your huge global brand back into town, I think there’s a welcome mat when you are someone who has become such a juggernaut as Taylor Swift,” Hubbs said.

At her Hall of Fame induction, Swift traced her ability to work across genres to the songwriting education she received in Nashville. The ceremony came 20 years after her debut album’s Oct. 24, 2006 release.

That education began after her family relocated from Pennsylvania to support her songwriting ambitions. A Sony publishing deal was in place by the time she was 14, when her mother drove her to Music Row writing sessions from Hendersonville High School. Her route to Big Machine Records included leaving an RCA development deal and catching Scott Borchetta’s attention at the Bluebird Cafe.

Swift addressed the question herself in 2014, as she prepared to release 1989: “To say I ‘left’ country music sounds very harsh,” she said. “It’s just a change in artistic direction.”

Follow Quote Catalog

Across the network

Academy Museum 6th Annual Gala in Partnership with Rolex
A wide black-and-white frame captures Swift standing alone on the event floor in a strapless pleated gown at the Academy Museum’s 6th Annual Gala in Los Angeles on Oct. 17, 2026. Photo by Emma McIntyre / Getty Images.
6th Annual Academy Museum Gala - Arrivals
At the 6th Annual Academy Museum Gala in Los Angeles on Oct. 17, 2026, Swift turns to look over her shoulder, revealing the back of her pleated strapless blue-grey gown. Photo by Amy Sussman / Getty Images.
2026 MTV Video Music Awards (VMAs) - Arrivals
Swift poses on the carpet in a black velvet halter top paired with a draped silver sequin skirt at the 2026 MTV Video Music Awards at Peacock Theater in Los Angeles on Sept. 27, 2026. Photo by Frazer Harrison / Getty Images.
1 / 3