Anthony Mackie on Dating and Age: “Women Don’t Like Older Men. They Like Younger, Fruitful Men”

Updated

Anthony Mackie speaking onstage at the Critics Choice Association's Celebration of Black Cinema & Television

Anthony Mackie, 48, was asked whether he’d get married again on Monday’s “Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen.” His answer turned into a debate with Cohen and fellow guest Jamie Dornan about whether women want to date older men.

“You know, I’m an older man and I feel like being an older man, women don’t like older men,” Mackie said.

“That is not true,” said Dornan, who stars with Mackie in “12 12 12.” He followed up with a question about the Captain America actor: “Older men with Marvel money?”

Anthony Mackie And Jamie Dornan In Conversation - "12 12 12"
At 92NY in New York City, Anthony Mackie and Jamie Dornan sit down for a discussion centered on their film “12 12 12” on November 11, 2026. Photo by Arturo Holmes / Getty Images.

Cohen joined in: “Yeah, right! Excuse me, older, jacked men who look like him?”

Anthony Mackie
Anthony Mackie photographed by Arturo Holmes / Getty Images.

Mackie held his position. “It’s hard as an older man. Women don’t like older men. They like younger, fruitful men,” he said.

He’d spoken about the difficulty of dating in February 2025, too, focusing on trust and vulnerability: “How do you know what someone really [wants] from you when all you want is to just be loved and appreciated? What does that look like?”

He also said, “I’m older and I don’t do the apps.”

Mackie married his childhood sweetheart, Sheletta Chapital, in December 2014 in Punta Cana, Dominican Republic. They split in 2018 and share 4 sons, whose names and ages they’ve kept private.

He’s largely kept his dating life private since the divorce, though he was seen kissing an unidentified woman in London’s Notting Hill in August 2025.

Follow Quote Catalog

Across the network

Anthony Mackie And Jamie Dornan In Conversation - "12 12 12"
At 92NY in New York City, Anthony Mackie and Jamie Dornan sit down for a discussion centered on their film “12 12 12” on November 11, 2026. Photo by Arturo Holmes / Getty Images.
The Critics Choice Association's 9th Annual Celebration Of Black Cinema & Television - Inside
At the Fairmont Century Plaza in Los Angeles, Anthony Mackie speaks onstage during the Critics Choice Association’s 9th Annual Celebration of Black Cinema & Television on November 16, 2026. Photo by Leon Bennett / Getty Images.
1 / 2